In other election news, Travis county has been hit with a lawsuit that challenges the electronic voting machines being used in our elections around here. Here is the article from the Austin American-Statesman, copied here in case you don't have a subscription to their website. My comments are included in [italics].
Lawsuit challenges Travis' electronic voting
Officials say voting is safe without paper ballots
By Steven Kreytak
Thursday, June 15, 2006
Seeking to keep Travis County from using its electronic voting system in upcoming elections, an Austin civil rights group claims in a lawsuit filed Wednesday that the system violates state law because it doesn't produce paper ballots.
The Texas Civil Rights Project sued Texas Secretary of State Roger Williams and Travis County Clerk Dana DeBeauvoir in state District Court.
The lawsuit argues that voters have no way of knowing whether the vote they cast is recorded or stored correctly by the eSlate system,[This is exactly the issue that I have had with the system from the beginning. I want to put a piece of paper in the ballot box and be able to look at it to verify my votes before I do so.-JT] which has been used in Travis County since 2002, and that electronic systems are prone to fraud and mistakes. The group wants an injunction to block use of the machines and cites government and media reports detailing problems with electronic voting in Texas and other states. [See BlackBoxVoting.org for some data.-JT]
Travis County has embraced the technology, switching to electronic voting for everything but absentee ballots. The federal government required Texas to put at least one electronic voting machine in each precinct by Jan. 1 so people with disabilities can easily vote.
DeBeauvoir and a spokesman for Williams, along with the founder of the Austin company that created eSlate, all rejected the claim that paper ballots are necessary for a fair and secure election.[duh, of course they would...-JT]
"I am not a lawyer[....-JT] but I kind of doubt that there is much of an argument," said DeBeauvoir, whose office runs elections in Travis County. "I believe that the system is accurate and secure the way it is."
David Hart, the founder of Hart InterCivic, said that more than 400 jurisdictions nationwide use the company's eSlate system, which uses tablet-size screens on which votes are cast with dials and buttons.
He said the system, which is not connected to the Internet, stores ballot information in three electronic places. In Travis County, it captures images of each ballot so electronic or manual recounts can be conducted.[Just because the system stores the info in three places, we are still not guaranteed security. There is still a long list of things that can go wrong.-JT]
"The eSlate system has got a lot of security built into it," he said.
The lawsuit was filed on behalf of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People of Austin and its president, Nelson Linder; Texas Attorney General candidate David Van Os;[hmm... political move to garner votes? I'm not for that, either...-JT] and Sonia Santana, identified as a Travis County voter and supporter of Van Os.
It also claims that Travis County voters are denied equal protection under the law because they are forced to use electronic systems while others in the state aren't — most counties still primarily use paper ballots.
Like the other electronic voting systems used in Texas, eSlate went through rigorous testing before being certified by state and federal officials, said Scott Haywood, a spokesman for Williams.
The lawsuit claims that more than half of states — but not Texas — require electronic voting systems to produce paper copies.
Hart's company has a machine that also prints paper ballot results. It is being reviewed by Williams' office for use in Texas elections, and DeBeauvoir said she'll present the option to the community if it's approved.
"I can run any kind of election this community wants," she said.[So what's the big deal?!?! Admit we made a mistake and switch to the paper ballot machines. It is not an issue of technology, it is an issue of pride. I hate politics...-JT]